Friday, June 3, 2011

Why are There TVs Everywhere I Go?

[I must warn you: this is going to be a bit of a rant. I don't even have a photo; I just need to get this off my chest. Perhaps by writing this and engaging with readers, I'll be able to come to terms with it and rationalize it, or maybe you will agree with me, and we can all advocate for public spaces without TVs...]

I'm starting to feel as if there are TVs everywhere the chicks and I go. Is this happening where you live? I'm not talking about people's houses; many of the houses we frequent either don't have TVs or have a TV in a subtle place, always off when visitors are in the home.

No, I'm talking about public places. I recently got into the habit of grabbing something quick and cheap for the chicks' dinner on the way home from a late swimming lesson (bad, I know.) Most of the places we went had TVs. Our dinners at home are admittedly not always riveting in their conversation given that we have one adult and two (tired by that time of day) small children. But at least we have some conversation. When the chicks sit down to eat in a cafe, and there's a TV on the wall, they can't help but stare. Of course--this is why the TV is there, right?

I just can't bear to sit across from my two children and have dinner while they are zombified. Even Ninna, at just-barely-turned-five, knows this is weird. She laughs about how she can't move her eyes away from the screen, and she has recently asked me, more than once, why there are TVs in all these places.

I remember, before our car-free days began, that there were even TVs at some of the gas stations. Can we really not pump gas for five minutes without a TV? I'm assuming this is entirely ad-driven and not consumer-driven. When we're pumping gas, there's nowhere to go but right in that spot...next to the TV. We're the perfect captive audience.

I've been bothered by this for awhile, but I finally came to a point of exasperation the other day when the chicks and I walked into the Y for Ninna's swimming lesson, and lo and behold...they had installed a huge flat-screen TV in the formerly peaceful lobby/cafe area--and it was on, of course. I momentarily felt vindicated when the man next to me asked the receptionist why they had added a TV. It's exciting to hear some sanity once in awhile. But my brain exploded when she responded with "well, it's because that area is a cafe!" That's the answer? If we're sitting at tables with each other eating a muffin and drinking tea, we must therefore be in the presence of a TV? I don't understand.

Days after Osama Bin Laden was killed, we stopped in at one of those by-the-slice pizza places after swimming lessons. It was a tiny little place, with just a few tables, and we were the only patrons. The requisite TV was on the wall, blaring the newscaster's commentary about Bin Laden's life and death.

My not-quite-three year old and just-turned-five year old don't need a play-by-play of Bin Laden's death, with thorough details. And when the time comes that I do think they are ready for this kind of information, they won't be getting it from corporate news, I can tell you that. So I did what apparently no one has ever done before in this establishment; I asked the owner if we could turn off the TV. He looked shocked, laughed when I told him why, and then, thankfully, turned it off.

I'm not trying to demonize TV as a whole. I know many wonderful people with TVs in their homes (I guess that would be almost everyone I know, right?) What we do or don't do with TV in the privacy of our homes is no one's business. And I'm not even suggesting that there are no uses whatsoever for TVs outside of the home; sports bars come to mind immediately. I loved watching Michigan State basketball games at a sports bar full of Spartans. But why is TV forced on my children every time we leave the house? Even in museums, you see video loops running on TVs about this subject or that. No one really ever sits down and watches them, but they are there, in our (public) space.

So tell me, dear readers, am I crazy? Does this bother anyone else? Will TV in public spaces one day go the way of smoking in restaurants, or are we headed for an Orwellian screen-in-every-room scenario? Or neither, and I'm just a little dramatic?

[Edited to add: I knew I was forgetting some more scenarios. I've already written about the movie forced on Bojey at the children's hair salon. And there are also walls full of flat-screen TVs in some of the metro stations here. Descending the escalator, you see throngs of people, each of whom is staring at the wall, blankly, watching the TVs. And you can include my children among these throngs, as well.]

18 comments:

Laura said...

I don't notice it as much around here- but then we don't go too many places and our favorite bar/restaurant is a sports bar but I think that the kids are so used to their presence that they don't look at them anymore. We don't have TV on during the week and it is not allowed AT ALL until they are two and then it's a few minutes of Elmo. Sadly when we were on vacay, the kids had a TV in their room and they were in heaven being able to watch some of the cartoons that their friends talk about. That being said, my kids would much prefer playing outside than sitting in a house watching some show!
I did pump gas at a station with a TV the other day... very strange!!!
(I just posted a vent recently on one of my blogs too- must be the season of venting!- My "Days" blog)

Emily said...

Oh I am right there with you. I travel for work a fair amount and it seems impossible to find a restaurant without tv on and blaring. I have even considered this product: http://www.amazon.com/TV-B-Gone-Universal-Remote-Control-Keychain/dp/B0006GD9CE
Then I decided to put on my big girl panties and just ask people to turn off the tv especially when no one is watching. People do look shocked, and if they refuse then I can politely take my business elsewhere.

I'm not sure how this crept up on us as a culture. We have a tv but we limit screen time to one kid tv show if that. After bedtime we occasionally watch an hour or so of tv but not often. We turned off our cable and only have netflix. I am saying this because I don't think our family is that weird. I don't think everyone has a tv on all the time - am I wrong?

We don't eat out as a family almost ever, but we would never, ever enjoy sitting down at a restaurant and watching tv with our dinner.

missharleyquinn said...

You are preaching to the choir! Just yesterday my IMps and I were having lunch, at a local hamburger type of joint. On the wall was a 60" plasma screen on the Fox News channel . The weird thing is that the volume was very low. So, we get to see the talking heads, read the scrolling marquee but have no idea what is being said. Why even have it up there?
I have very unrealistic moments where I long for a little house tucked far away, where we have a radio somewhere in the house to keep track of the rest of the world and maybe a lap top for visiting fun sites every so often...otherwise we'd be left to the trees and the sky, the birds and the blooms.

Allison said...

Maybe more than TVs everywhere, I hate ADS everywhere. They're EVERYWHERE. I'm sorry, I don't need you telling me what I "need".

amandara said...

I am in total agreement. I have asked the receptionist to turn off the Tv in the waiting room before when no one was watching it, and they did. I feel it is harder to avoid when it is at local grocery stores and such while waiting in lines. I did however just write a thank you to panera bread for being TV free.

Jill said...

I have a million things I could say about this subject, but will limit my thoughts to this: It's a pretty messed up world when a woman breastfeeding her baby in public is scandalous, but televisions blaring news of bin Laden's death and adverts for sexual dysfunction/KY are totally acceptable.

greeniezona said...

I *hate* this. I am the sort of person who likes to have a book with me everywhere I go. And it's just nearly impossible to block out both the noise of other people AND a tv in order to really concentrate on my book. Once I took the bus as a connection from my train and the driver put in a DVD! With those little tiny screens no more than three feet from any person's head, and of course the volume blaring!

I really, really want one of those TV-be-gone remotes. I am hoping someone gets me one for my birthday.

Andrea said...

Wow...I don't think it's that bad here (yet) in rural Maine (no gas station TVs and most restaurants we go to don't have TVs, with the exception of our favorite pizza place; though once I was stuck in a tire place for 5 hours (in a blizzard, getting my snow tires on), with no book and no knitting and the only magazines were guy or celebrity mags, and the giant TV was stuck on ESPN...personal version of hell right there), but you are definitely not crazy. I think people are afraid to think, so they need noise and sound filling their brains constantly (or the corporate machine wants us all to be in that state). I have little doubt it will only get worse (TVs in schools, on grocery carts, picnic tables, beaches, remote mountain peaks).

(P.S. YOu might want to check your comment settings? I have such a hard time posting comments here using my google acct.)

MaryAnne said...

I hate TVs in non-sports-bar restaurants. From your post, it sounds as if they are more ubiquitous in Canada than the Boston metro area...

Melissa Taylor said...

good point - I don't think we get out enough to be bothered but I can totally see what you mean. I just wrote a post about boredom and why we should want that -- and stop trying to fill every second for our kids and ourselves. TV just numbs us.

Kirsten said...

I'm also irritated by TVs in all the restaurants. It's so loud with the combination of the TV and the music that's playing, that it's very difficult to speak to anyone.

There are TVs on our busses here. They don't have any programming on them .... yet.

Marilia said...

Good to know I´m not alone in hating the TV found anywhere. It bothers the hell out of me, just how it does to you and your other commenters.

But if we happen to one day evolve, take our society to a next level, I think that you are right, it will be admonished like smoking.

For this, we have a long way ahead of us in changing the value´s system we are all brought up in.

HappyMama said...

Ug, I live in Virginia and there are TVs *everywhere.* At the post office. At Jiffy Lube. Even all over Walmart. Anywhere that people need to wait for more than a minute, businesses seem to think that you need to have a TV. Uggg. I am *not* a fan of all of the noise-- or of the very-non-child-friendly things I've heard on the news being broadcast in public places.

I, for one, love silence, and a minute to collect my thoughts!

Jaimie said...

Can I tell you all how happy it makes me to see the novel-length comments you've written in response to this? I love knowing that you're all concerned about this as well. I'd honestly love it so much if we had a no-tv-in-public-spaces law.

I really think I need that tv-be-gone thing. I think I could use it without feeling bad or worried about it, even.

Leah said...

There is a TV in our pediatrician's waiting room. I always think it's odd, because every time I take either kid for a check-up, we get a handout that reminds me not to let them watch too much TV...

Sarah said...

Yes, I agree. There is media EVERYWHERE and usually it is totally inappropriate for children. But then, I think that our culture is not child/family-oriented, which is a sad, sad state of affairs.

The other thing that drives me batty is that my children are offered candy everywhere we go. A restaurant, the grocery store, a children's class, the doctor's office (huh?). I just don't get it. At. All.

I just discovered your blog. It's lovely. I grew up in Northern VT but we never went to Montreal. I find that totally odd!

Deanna said...

I agree that we do not need TVs everywhere. Even in restaurants/bars. Have one or two in the separate bar area, not where people just are eating.
But, also, I must add cell phones. They drive me crazy.
We are all human beings and need interaction with each other. Lets put those phones in our pockets and look up and smile at each other and say hi.
Yikes.

Only in Louisiana ~ documenting the adventures we call Life! said...

You have hit the nail on the head with this post - I so agree with what you are saying. I am always the one in our house that begs for the TV to be off. It really isn't a huge problem (thankfully) but I am always on top of it and always suggesting alternatives when one of the children tries to turn it on. Books, books and more books! Fortunately, they love to read. Also, I have only one TV in the house! However, it is a societal battle as you have pointed out in such a perfect way...going to bookmark your post!